Consider the thirteen projects below. Your charge is to evaluate each project individually with three criteria:
- How difficult would this project have been to estimate?
- How difficult would this project have been to construct?
- How difficult would it have been for you to make a profit on this job?
A score of 5 rates this project very difficult while a score of 1 is low in its difficulty for each of the three categories.
Directions: You may vote online on this page by completing the three questions at the bottom of each entry and clicking the "submit" button at the bottom of this form.
Candidate 1
Download all 24 project images | Click on the photos above for a larger view
Candidate 2
Download all 54 project images | Click on the photos above for a larger view
Candidate 3
Download all 4 project images | Click on the photos above for a larger view
Candidate 4
Download all 6 project images | Click on the photos above for a larger view
Candidate 5
Download all 15 project images | Click on the photos above for a larger view
Candidate 6
Download all 36 project images | Click on the photos above for a larger view
Project overview
This California “cliff-hanger” has a mat slab footing ranging from 4-ft to 4-ft 6-in. thick with three keyways (lugs) below 3-ft x 3-ft x 50-ft long. This consumed 560 cu. yds. of concrete with an topping slab 6-in. thick. Only four square corners existed for the foundation walls. The rest were acute and obtuse angles with intersecting interior walls at off angles. Several columns were required between 30 and 40-ft in height. The job consisted of a five-level, concrete home, four of those levels below grade.
The project started by drilling 47 36-in. caissons, which went down between 40 and 60-ft in depth. After hitting major groundwater, using pumps and holding tanks, multiple mat slabs and structural slab levels and covering slabs, in the end, over 2,700 yards of concrete was poured, over 1,000,000 pounds of steel set, thousands of pieces of hardware, and 9,000 square feet of structural deck shored. |
|
|
Location |
Laguna Beach, California |
| |
Total Sq. Ft. Plan: |
11,000 |
| |
Total Lin. Ft. Wall: |
Not provided |
| |
Concrete Used: |
501 cu. yds (walls)
812 cu. yds (caisons)
375 cu. yds (concrete decks)
1,050 cu. yds (footings) |
| |
Steel Used: |
128 tons (walls)
320 tons (caisons)
63.4 tons (footings) |
| |
Wall Heights: |
25-ft up to 54-ft |
| |
Wall Thickness: |
10-in. to 18-in. |
| |
|
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
Candidate 7
Download all 5 project images | Click on the photos above for a larger view
Candidate 8
Download all 15 project images | Click on the photos above for a larger view
Candidate 9
Download all 8 project images | Click on the photos above for a larger view
Candidate 10
Download all 12 project images | Click on the photos above for a larger view
Project overview
The challenge of this project included 25 different elevations with footing widths ranging from 4-ft to 12-ft wide. Continuous #7 bars were required in all footings. Built into the side of a cliff, some walls were required to be 17-ft tall and at each end of the building a 17-ft tall fireplace was cast. The ½-acre site sits 150-ft above the river below and contains 17 units in three buildings, all with limited access.
While digging foundations, the engineer decided the original design would not work and the entire structure changed, forcing us to adapt during excavation.
The project required large mats of steel and 14 different concrete placements by pump. In all, more than 2,000 man hours were logged on the project for our scope of excavation, foundations, flatwork and spoils removal. |
|
|
Location |
Lakewood, Ohio |
| |
Total Sq. Ft. Plan: |
12,600 |
| |
Total Lin. Ft. Wall: |
1,445 |
| |
Concrete Used: |
375 cu. yds (walls)
235 cu. yds (footings) |
| |
Steel Used: |
8.0 tons (walls)
0.5 tons (footings) |
| |
Wall Heights: |
6-ft to 17-ft (ranging) |
| |
Wall Thickness: |
8-in. to 14” (ranging) |
| |
|
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
Candidate 11
Download all 8 project images | Click on the photos above for a larger view
Candidate 12
Download all 6 project images | Click on the photos above for a larger view
Project overview
This project included complex corners and piers at walk-out walls. Additionally, a curved wall was prepared with a stone ledge on the exterior and a foot ledge on the interior.
Our expertise with total station made the difference in this project with the complex foundation received from the architect in CAD. Due to the elevation changes and the proximity to the lake, a pump placed the concrete for the entire project and the result was a high-quality, complex foundation for this owner’s new home. |
|
|
Location |
Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin |
| |
Total Sq. Ft. Plan: |
6,200 |
| |
Total Lin. Ft. Wall: |
540 |
| |
Concrete Used: |
225 cu. yds (walls)
104 cu. yds (footings) |
| |
Steel Used: |
6 tons (walls)
1.5 tons (footings) |
| |
Wall Heights: |
4-ft, 13-ft 2-in. |
| |
Wall Thickness: |
8-in., 10-in., 14-in., 16-in., 18-in. and 22-in. |
| |
|
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
Candidate 13
Download all 10 project images | Click on the photos above for a larger view
To verify you are human (and not a spam generating script), please indicate which character below is a different color:

Please make sure you have have selected ratings for all thirteen projects and answered the spam check above before submitting your ballot below. Note: To insure fairness, all voting submissions are stamped with date, time and IP address. Please do not vote more than once.